Wednesday, January 20, 2010

2.4 Potential Difference

Previous sections:
1. Introduction
2. Electrostatic
2.1 Coulomb's Law
2.2 Gauss's Law of electrostatic
2.3 Electric field in materials

2.4 Potential Difference

Recalling that for electrostatic, the electric field must satisfy the below two equations at all points of space and time.

∇.D=ρ

∇xE=0

In this section, we shall set out to prove the second equation, which reads "the curl of E is equals to zero". As mentioned in section 2.2, the symbol that looks like an inverted triangle, ∇, is called nabla and it is actually a vector (d/dx, d/dy, d/dz). We shall defer the mathematics to later and try first to understand the physical significance of ∇xE=0.

The past few sections described, in general, the behaviour of electrical charges under the influence of an electrical field. Up to this point, we would already know that a positive electrical charge moves along the 'force lines' of an electrical field. The electrical field 'points' from a positive charge, say in point A, towards a negative charge, in point B. This is equivalent in saying that there is a potential difference between point A and B, which moves the electrical charge. Although the word 'potential' is common among science and engineering students, many take this word for granted and do not really understand what it means. Therefore, before going any further, I will attempt to answer the following two fundamental physics questions regarding 'potential'. However, if you are already an adept physics student you can skip this part and go straight to the section on 'potential energy' below.

What is potential (from physics point of view)?

In physics, it is said that energy is conserved. No energy is created or destroyed. It is only changed from one form to another. When you throw a ball towards a wall, it has kinetic energy. When the ball hits the wall and bounces back towards you, portion of the kinetic energy is converted to sound (that is why you will hear a 'thud' when the ball hits the wall); part of the energy is converted to heat due to the friction of the ball with the wall and air (although this is small); and some of the energy is also converted to heat due to atomic collisions within the ball when it deforms as it hits the wall (amount of energy converted here depends on the material of the ball). The total energy of the ball before and after the collision with the wall is exactly the same.

But a peculiar case happens when we lift a heavy object against gravity. Obviously when we lift an object against gravity, we need energy. But if energy is not destroyed nor created, then where does the energy go to? It is not sound or heat or any kind of energy that we can clearly measure. But the energy is clearly not lost because if we now release that object, it picks up speed, gains kinetic energy and thus falls towards the floor. The energy is actually 'stored' within that object and we say that the object has gained potential energy, i.e. potential to do 'work' or release energy.

How does a potential 'do' work?

We can never know the absolute amount of potential energy that an object has, we can only know or measure the difference. For example, when we lift an object a certain distance above the ground, we can only know that this object has gained a certain amount of potential energy, proportional to the distance it has been lifted. But what is the absolute energy it has? How much potential energy does it have in the first place? Is it possible that even before we lift the object, it already has a lot of energy stored in it? We can never know. This is because we cannot measure or observe this 'stored' energy directly. Therefore what is important is the magnitude of the difference of the energy, not the absolute value of it. Because we are only concerned with the difference and not the absolute value, it presents us with a flexibility to define what potential energy is.

If we now reverse the process i.e. we release the object from a certain height and let it fall to the ground. This object will release the 'stored' potential energy, which is equivalent to the difference of potential energy between the height it was released and the ground. In other words, an object will attempt to do work to release the 'stored' energy when there is a potential difference. This difference can be a postive or a negative one, depending whether it is A - B or B - A. It is, however, of no real physical significance whether it is positive or negative. In practice, it is common that we define the value of 'potential' mathematically such that energy is released when the object move from a high potential to a low potential, i.e. when A - B > 0 then energy is released and work is done by the system; but when B - A > 0, work needs to be done on the system instead. (although students should take note that there are special cases where it is defined that energy is released when moving from low potential to high potential, this is only a change of definition and does not affect what we observe in the real world).

A way to imagine this convention is to to take the analogy of river flowing from the mountain tops to the sea. River will always flow (i.e doing work) from a higher place to a lower place (i.e. high potential to low potential). When the surface is flat, the water does not flow (i.e. no potential difference)

Potential Energy

If an electrical charge move from point A to point B under the influence of an electrical field, we could have as well said that this is due to a potential difference between A and B. This potential energy must have been stored when we moved, for example, a positive electrical charge against the electrical field. Just as when we lift a ball off the ground and release it, the ball would fall back to ground; so would the electrical charge if moved against the electrical field and then released, it will move back to its original position.

This stored potential energy due to moving a charge against electrical field can be calculated by using the simple equation:

Energy = Force x Distance.

However, if the force acts along a curved line, then the distance which the force acts may then not be trivial to calculate. We can still do this by assuming that a curved line is formed by a series of small arrows. The smaller the arrows, the closer it matches to the curve. In this way, we can calculate the energy that is stored in an electrical charge by tracing the force, F, along the small arrows. Energy is now equal to force x distance, i.e. F . dx where dx is the length of the very small arrow (Note: both F and dx are vectors. By taking the dot product of F and dx, we find the component of F in the direction of the small arrows.) When dx becomes infinitesimally small, this becomes an integration: ∫ F. dx

but F=qE, therefore

q ∫ E. dx = -Energy (to move from A to B). The negative sign is to indicate that work is done when moving an electrical charge against electrical field. As described above, this is just a convention such that we all agree energy is released when a charge moves from high potential to low potential points.

Energy/q = - ∫ E. dx
V = - ∫ E . dx

Therefore, potential difference is just the energy per charge. Now bringing the dx over the other side of the equation and considering only a small change in potential leads to:

- dV / dx = E

In 3-dimension, d /dx becomes (d/dx, d/dy, d/dz) which is equivalent to ∇. This suggests that E=-∇V, where ∇V is read as grad V.

Now, it can be shown (mathematically) that a charge does not gain any net energy by moving from A to B and then back to A again. E.g. the charge gains energy when moving from A to B and releases this same amount of energy when going back from B to A. We call this a conservative field, i.e. the net energy gain depends solely on the end points (initial and final position). You can take an electrical charge on the planet Earth, take it to the moon and the bring it back to Earth but at 1 cm away from the original position - the net energy that it gains or loses is still due to that 1 cm distance. The fact that you had brought the charge to the moon and back makes no difference at all!

So if we move an electrical charge from A to 'somewhere' and back to exactly A, no net energy is gained (or equivalently, no work is done). Mathematically, we write this as

∫ E. dl =0

where the integration is taken over a closed loop. A loop is like a line where the beginning point is the same as the ending point, therefore there is not net energy gained. From Stoke's theorem we obtain ∫ E. dl = ∫∇xE dl =0, i.e ∇xE = 0, which is what we set out to prove.

At first glance, this seems like an immensely stupid equation because we are calculating the energy to bring a charge from A to B and then back to A again, which is essentially zero. It sure sounds more useful if we are actually calculating the energy from point A to some other point in space. But the purpose of the equation is to help us in characterising electric field in static conditions, it is suppose to give us a set of 'criteria', if you will, to fulfill if the electric field is static and that is exactly what the equation does. The physical meaning of the equation is to say that in the case of electrostatic, the electrical field is conservative - that is the potential difference is independent of path (travelled by the charge) and only depends on the displacement (initial and final position) of the electrical charges. We will see later that this is not always the case. It is useful to note that the statement "Electrical field is conservative" also gives information on how to calculate the potential difference between two points.

So the equations ∇.D=ρ and ∇xE=0, together with the bounday conditions, which we will talk about in the next section, are all the information you need to know about electrostatic field.

Kirchoff's Voltage Law

As a final note, it is important to note that the above relates to Kirchoff's Voltage Law, which states that the voltage drop in a (closed) loop is zero. This is a mathematical consequence of ∫ E. dl = 0. If we have a battery, however, then the electrical field is no longer conservative, the situation is no longer considered as electrostatic and therefore this equation is no longer true in such situations.

Thursday, January 14, 2010

辩手,评判们:是谁赢了这场比赛?

我在辩论界已混了至少15年。虽然 ,还是有比我更老的前辈,但是我看过的辩论比赛绝对不少,可说是经验不浅。而这么多年来令我最讨厌的就是看到辩论员们辛辛苦苦为一场比赛准备了这么久,却被误判而输。

所以,我恳请大家 -- 所有辩论老前辈,现任以及过去的辩手或是评判帮帮手。帮我看一下这一场“辩论赛”到底是谁胜了?是不是代表Allah专利权的那一方获胜?若是,我 “切”!!!

Monday, January 11, 2010

Principles, not sensitivities!

The best speech that I have seen so far related to the recent "Allah" ban in Malaysia was not from PKR, DAP or PAS. Surprisingly, it's from an UMNO member. And I'm not being sarcastic.

You can read Tengku Razaleigh's full speech here. The speech was given at the Institute of South East Asia Studies Regional Outlook Forum 2010 at Singapore on Jan 7 2010.

The following are the arguments that I am most impressed with, "...a government whose primary response to a public issue is sunk in the elastic goo of “sensitivities” rather than founded on principle..." and "...It is about doing what is right rather than protecting arbitrary feelings. If feelings diverge from what is right and just, then it’s time to show some leadership."

A leadership that is based on "sensitivities" of a particular group will always flip-flop on his decisions, contradicting constitution and law on the way of doing so. A leader whom is not guided by principles, will allow himself/herself to be led by the nose.

If our PM's leadership was founded on principles rather than to satisfy his need to stay in power or to satisfy the sensitivities of a group of extremists, this is what he would have said,

"
I understand that the recent court ruling on the usage of Kalimah "Allah" has caused concerns among various people, Muslims and Christians alike. First of all, I would like to assure everyone that everybody has the freedom and right to practice their own religion. No one should force someone's religion onto another, be it Islam or Christianity.

Any religion, and especially Islam, emphasizes peace and harmony. Muslims are compassionate. And Muslims must more so show this virtue during the time when some of us have a slight disagreement with our Christian brethren. Let us not forget that they are also our fellow countrymen and neighbours, whom we have lived together in harmony for so many years. Everyone deserves compassion and patience from a Muslim, what more if they are our fellow countrymen? Therefore, we must refrain from any violence act and engage in a dialogue to solve our differences, as Nabi Muhammad S.A.W. would have.

The usage of Kalimah "Allah" by non-Muslims though may be an issue, it is neither the most important issue facing Islam today nor is it the most important teaching from the Quran or Bible. There is no point in getting the Kalimah right, but indulging in corruption, ignorance and violence at the same time. It is an issue. I am not saying it isn't. But it is not the most important issue facing the Islam faith or the Muslims of Malaysia right now. I assure you, that we will seek a solution to this, and we shall seek it through inter-faith discussions and forums, not through violence.

The ruling is now under appeal. I urge to let the court process to take place and respect the judge's decision. There is a reason for the court and the law to exist. Although it may not be perfect, we must respect the process and to amend the law through the right process. And that is through the Parliament, not through the streets or violence or by inciting hatred. In this case, as the leader of the majority party in the Parliament, I shall take the lead in proposing an amendment to the relevant laws to rectify the problem. I shall do this, only after in consultation with various parties and after sufficient inter-faith dialogues have been made. Meanwhile, let us be patient and respect the judge's decision.

Therefore, I urge everyone to be calm and patient during this time. Show what real Islam is about. Show what being a Malaysian is about."


This, is what I would said if I am the PM. He should have been neutral. But instead, he chose to blatantly side with the Muslim extremists.

Sunday, January 10, 2010

雪州513

翻看着以前的帖子,我发现我在3个月前早已对上星期在雪州所发生的一连串事件做过类似的推测:

1。在雪州制造骚乱(迷你513)
2。内政部长利用“牛头”事件来合理化这次的示威。

两个,全中!

我进一步推测,近期内警察的调查结果会是:放火烧屋的恶徒,不是回教极端份子,而是一些亲反对党的非回教徒。从而,又再把责任推向给反对党。

希望我的推测是不对的。

Saturday, January 9, 2010

Great Britain covered in snow!



Can you recognise this?
It's Great Britain covered in snow (actual satellite picture).
I'm at the south east corner.
Freeeeeeeeeezing cold...........

Friday, January 8, 2010

Ruin and run...

Perhaps, there's no one to blame for Malaysia's plight. It's all due to bad pronunciation really:


Najib: Run the country to the best of your ability!

Ministers: Ruin the country!

Najib: No, I said, "Run", not "Ruin"

Ministers: Yeah, ruin! not run.

Najib: Run!

Ministers: Ruin la. I said ruin what.

Najib: Run, Run, Run! I said run the country!

Ministers: Ruin, Ruin Ruin. We'll ruin the country!




Police: I warn you first, you can only have protest. After that, run, or I'll catch you!

Mat Rempit: Ok. After protest, ruin. Find church to ruin. Got it.

Police: No. I said run.

Mat Rempit:Ruin?

Police: Run. R-U-N. Rrrrrrun.

Mat Rempit: I heard you the first time. Ruin.

Police: Run!! I said "run". It's R-U-I-N without the 'I'.

Mat Rempit: I no ruin? how can? then who ruin la?

Police: I said run. If not, I'll put you in lockup.

Mat Rempit: Ok Ok. Flip-flop lagi. I'll ruin. I don't want to stay in the lockup.

Police: No. I meant run. After that, RUN!

Mat Rempit: Ooooh ok. Now I get it, after I ruin, I run. Roger that!

钱不是万恶之源。。。

它,才是万恶之源。

万恶当然不是指所有的恶,而是指 "数量极多,而且品种繁复的恶行"。我方认为世上穷凶极恶的恶行都来自xxx。

家庭暴力,是为了钱。但,再怎么凶,家庭暴力不是恐怖主义;
恐怖主义,是恶。但,再怎么残忍,恐怖主义不是为了钱;
麻原彰晃,既是恐怖主义也是为了钱。但他不是霸权;

可是xxx,比他们都还恶。
它,聚集了霸权、金钱、以及恐怖主义于一身。
它为了钱和权,无所不做。
它是贪、嗔、痴。
它“异化了人与钱之间的关系”。
它是万恶之首的淫。

可是它不是钱。它来自马来西亚。