我在辩论界已混了至少15年。虽然 ,还是有比我更老的前辈,但是我看过的辩论比赛绝对不少,可说是经验不浅。而这么多年来令我最讨厌的就是看到辩论员们辛辛苦苦为一场比赛准备了这么久,却被误判而输。
所以,我恳请大家 -- 所有辩论老前辈,现任以及过去的辩手或是评判帮帮手。帮我看一下这一场“辩论赛”到底是谁胜了?是不是代表Allah专利权的那一方获胜?若是,我 “切”!!!
Thursday, January 14, 2010
Monday, January 11, 2010
Principles, not sensitivities!
The best speech that I have seen so far related to the recent "Allah" ban in Malaysia was not from PKR, DAP or PAS. Surprisingly, it's from an UMNO member. And I'm not being sarcastic.
You can read Tengku Razaleigh's full speech here. The speech was given at the Institute of South East Asia Studies Regional Outlook Forum 2010 at Singapore on Jan 7 2010.
The following are the arguments that I am most impressed with, "...a government whose primary response to a public issue is sunk in the elastic goo of “sensitivities” rather than founded on principle..." and "...It is about doing what is right rather than protecting arbitrary feelings. If feelings diverge from what is right and just, then it’s time to show some leadership."
A leadership that is based on "sensitivities" of a particular group will always flip-flop on his decisions, contradicting constitution and law on the way of doing so. A leader whom is not guided by principles, will allow himself/herself to be led by the nose.
If our PM's leadership was founded on principles rather than to satisfy his need to stay in power or to satisfy the sensitivities of a group of extremists, this is what he would have said,
"I understand that the recent court ruling on the usage of Kalimah "Allah" has caused concerns among various people, Muslims and Christians alike. First of all, I would like to assure everyone that everybody has the freedom and right to practice their own religion. No one should force someone's religion onto another, be it Islam or Christianity.
Any religion, and especially Islam, emphasizes peace and harmony. Muslims are compassionate. And Muslims must more so show this virtue during the time when some of us have a slight disagreement with our Christian brethren. Let us not forget that they are also our fellow countrymen and neighbours, whom we have lived together in harmony for so many years. Everyone deserves compassion and patience from a Muslim, what more if they are our fellow countrymen? Therefore, we must refrain from any violence act and engage in a dialogue to solve our differences, as Nabi Muhammad S.A.W. would have.
The usage of Kalimah "Allah" by non-Muslims though may be an issue, it is neither the most important issue facing Islam today nor is it the most important teaching from the Quran or Bible. There is no point in getting the Kalimah right, but indulging in corruption, ignorance and violence at the same time. It is an issue. I am not saying it isn't. But it is not the most important issue facing the Islam faith or the Muslims of Malaysia right now. I assure you, that we will seek a solution to this, and we shall seek it through inter-faith discussions and forums, not through violence.
The ruling is now under appeal. I urge to let the court process to take place and respect the judge's decision. There is a reason for the court and the law to exist. Although it may not be perfect, we must respect the process and to amend the law through the right process. And that is through the Parliament, not through the streets or violence or by inciting hatred. In this case, as the leader of the majority party in the Parliament, I shall take the lead in proposing an amendment to the relevant laws to rectify the problem. I shall do this, only after in consultation with various parties and after sufficient inter-faith dialogues have been made. Meanwhile, let us be patient and respect the judge's decision.
Therefore, I urge everyone to be calm and patient during this time. Show what real Islam is about. Show what being a Malaysian is about."
This, is what I would said if I am the PM. He should have been neutral. But instead, he chose to blatantly side with the Muslim extremists.
You can read Tengku Razaleigh's full speech here. The speech was given at the Institute of South East Asia Studies Regional Outlook Forum 2010 at Singapore on Jan 7 2010.
The following are the arguments that I am most impressed with, "...a government whose primary response to a public issue is sunk in the elastic goo of “sensitivities” rather than founded on principle..." and "...It is about doing what is right rather than protecting arbitrary feelings. If feelings diverge from what is right and just, then it’s time to show some leadership."
A leadership that is based on "sensitivities" of a particular group will always flip-flop on his decisions, contradicting constitution and law on the way of doing so. A leader whom is not guided by principles, will allow himself/herself to be led by the nose.
If our PM's leadership was founded on principles rather than to satisfy his need to stay in power or to satisfy the sensitivities of a group of extremists, this is what he would have said,
"I understand that the recent court ruling on the usage of Kalimah "Allah" has caused concerns among various people, Muslims and Christians alike. First of all, I would like to assure everyone that everybody has the freedom and right to practice their own religion. No one should force someone's religion onto another, be it Islam or Christianity.
Any religion, and especially Islam, emphasizes peace and harmony. Muslims are compassionate. And Muslims must more so show this virtue during the time when some of us have a slight disagreement with our Christian brethren. Let us not forget that they are also our fellow countrymen and neighbours, whom we have lived together in harmony for so many years. Everyone deserves compassion and patience from a Muslim, what more if they are our fellow countrymen? Therefore, we must refrain from any violence act and engage in a dialogue to solve our differences, as Nabi Muhammad S.A.W. would have.
The usage of Kalimah "Allah" by non-Muslims though may be an issue, it is neither the most important issue facing Islam today nor is it the most important teaching from the Quran or Bible. There is no point in getting the Kalimah right, but indulging in corruption, ignorance and violence at the same time. It is an issue. I am not saying it isn't. But it is not the most important issue facing the Islam faith or the Muslims of Malaysia right now. I assure you, that we will seek a solution to this, and we shall seek it through inter-faith discussions and forums, not through violence.
The ruling is now under appeal. I urge to let the court process to take place and respect the judge's decision. There is a reason for the court and the law to exist. Although it may not be perfect, we must respect the process and to amend the law through the right process. And that is through the Parliament, not through the streets or violence or by inciting hatred. In this case, as the leader of the majority party in the Parliament, I shall take the lead in proposing an amendment to the relevant laws to rectify the problem. I shall do this, only after in consultation with various parties and after sufficient inter-faith dialogues have been made. Meanwhile, let us be patient and respect the judge's decision.
Therefore, I urge everyone to be calm and patient during this time. Show what real Islam is about. Show what being a Malaysian is about."
This, is what I would said if I am the PM. He should have been neutral. But instead, he chose to blatantly side with the Muslim extremists.
Sunday, January 10, 2010
Saturday, January 9, 2010
Great Britain covered in snow!
Friday, January 8, 2010
Ruin and run...
Perhaps, there's no one to blame for Malaysia's plight. It's all due to bad pronunciation really:
Najib: Run the country to the best of your ability!
Ministers: Ruin the country!
Najib: No, I said, "Run", not "Ruin"
Ministers: Yeah, ruin! not run.
Najib: Run!
Ministers: Ruin la. I said ruin what.
Najib: Run, Run, Run! I said run the country!
Ministers: Ruin, Ruin Ruin. We'll ruin the country!
Police: I warn you first, you can only have protest. After that, run, or I'll catch you!
Mat Rempit: Ok. After protest, ruin. Find church to ruin. Got it.
Police: No. I said run.
Mat Rempit:Ruin?
Police: Run. R-U-N. Rrrrrrun.
Mat Rempit: I heard you the first time. Ruin.
Police: Run!! I said "run". It's R-U-I-N without the 'I'.
Mat Rempit: I no ruin? how can? then who ruin la?
Police: I said run. If not, I'll put you in lockup.
Mat Rempit: Ok Ok. Flip-flop lagi. I'll ruin. I don't want to stay in the lockup.
Police: No. I meant run. After that, RUN!
Mat Rempit: Ooooh ok. Now I get it, after I ruin, I run. Roger that!
Najib: Run the country to the best of your ability!
Ministers: Ruin the country!
Najib: No, I said, "Run", not "Ruin"
Ministers: Yeah, ruin! not run.
Najib: Run!
Ministers: Ruin la. I said ruin what.
Najib: Run, Run, Run! I said run the country!
Ministers: Ruin, Ruin Ruin. We'll ruin the country!
Police: I warn you first, you can only have protest. After that, run, or I'll catch you!
Mat Rempit: Ok. After protest, ruin. Find church to ruin. Got it.
Police: No. I said run.
Mat Rempit:Ruin?
Police: Run. R-U-N. Rrrrrrun.
Mat Rempit: I heard you the first time. Ruin.
Police: Run!! I said "run". It's R-U-I-N without the 'I'.
Mat Rempit: I no ruin? how can? then who ruin la?
Police: I said run. If not, I'll put you in lockup.
Mat Rempit: Ok Ok. Flip-flop lagi. I'll ruin. I don't want to stay in the lockup.
Police: No. I meant run. After that, RUN!
Mat Rempit: Ooooh ok. Now I get it, after I ruin, I run. Roger that!
钱不是万恶之源。。。
它,才是万恶之源。
万恶当然不是指所有的恶,而是指 "数量极多,而且品种繁复的恶行"。我方认为世上穷凶极恶的恶行都来自xxx。
家庭暴力,是为了钱。但,再怎么凶,家庭暴力不是恐怖主义;
恐怖主义,是恶。但,再怎么残忍,恐怖主义不是为了钱;
麻原彰晃,既是恐怖主义也是为了钱。但他不是霸权;
可是xxx,比他们都还恶。
它,聚集了霸权、金钱、以及恐怖主义于一身。
它为了钱和权,无所不做。
它是贪、嗔、痴。
它“异化了人与钱之间的关系”。
它是万恶之首的淫。
可是它不是钱。它来自马来西亚。
万恶当然不是指所有的恶,而是指 "数量极多,而且品种繁复的恶行"。我方认为世上穷凶极恶的恶行都来自xxx。
家庭暴力,是为了钱。但,再怎么凶,家庭暴力不是恐怖主义;
恐怖主义,是恶。但,再怎么残忍,恐怖主义不是为了钱;
麻原彰晃,既是恐怖主义也是为了钱。但他不是霸权;
可是xxx,比他们都还恶。
它,聚集了霸权、金钱、以及恐怖主义于一身。
它为了钱和权,无所不做。
它是贪、嗔、痴。
它“异化了人与钱之间的关系”。
它是万恶之首的淫。
可是它不是钱。它来自马来西亚。
Thursday, January 7, 2010
A gifted child...
Son: Dad, I want to quit school.
Me: What?! But why?
Son: School is so boring. They are teaching calculus, which I already knew since I was 6, and they are still learning Newtonian physics. When are they going to start on quantum mechanics?
Me: Yes, you are a gifted child. But do stay in school, dear. If you find the academic side of the school is boring, try joining student organisations, like the Chinese Language Society or debate team.
Son: Like what you did when you attended high school?
Me: Yes. You can learn about people relationship, people management, organisational skills but most of all it is fun! You could also do some charity work in the local community. By helping the poor and the weak, you get to see things from other people's point of view and it will change your life. You could also play some games, mix with people, go after girls, you know, those things that other high school boys do?! (laugh)
Son: But what's the point?
Me: What's the point of going after girls? (*Gasp*)
Son: No, dad. (=.= "') I know about going after girls. I meant, what's the point of learning people skills, etc ...
Me: Great to hear you are interested in girls already (*wink*). Well, there's a lot more to school than just knowledge, you know. And that's certainly true as well when you step into the society to work, which will happen soon enough. To make the right decision, you must learn how to appreciate the people around you, the culture and history. To realise a plan, you must make people to work with you. You don't expect to get everything done by yourself, do you?
Son: Didnt' Einstein developed theory of relativity all by himself?
Me: No. First of all, without Newton and all the subsequent scientist's groundbreaking work in gravity, there would be no theory of relativity. They were the necessary foundation to Einstein's work. Let's not forget that he had to rely on Eddington to verify his theory. And most important of all, Einstein was not just a physicist, he was also actively involved in politics and was influential in both the World War 1 and 2.
Son: Really? I see.
Me: Your knowledge must have a positive impact to yourself, to the people around you and ultimately to humanity, but you would not be able to do that if you do not first appreciate and respect the people around you. What good is knowledge if it doesn't help yourself and those around you?
Son: Does it always come in that order? Self, people around me, and then humanity? Sounds a bit far-fetched don't you think? Humanity, eh?
Me: Your sphere of influence grows in that order - you first influence yourself, the people around you and then, if you are lucky, humanity. But the importance is in the reverse order. Always place others before yourself. You will never know though, that some day you may be some one great and influential. But even if you are not the leader of the world, you are always important to me, to your family and those around you.
Son: Thanks dad.
Me: You are welcome. Remember, stay in school. Spend the extra time with friends and learn more about people, it's much more complex than quantum mechanics and string theory, trust me on it. There's no hurry in learning quantum physics and string theory. You can always accelerate your academic skills after high school when you start your university education. So what do you think? You feel better about school now?
Son: I guess so. I will check out the notice board tomorrow to see if any student project interests me.
Me: Good. Now, go out and play with your friends.
Son: OK. But I think I would go to my room and finish the book "The strange theory of light and matter" by Feynman. I am already at the last chapter. Love you, dad.
Me: Love you too.
Me: What?! But why?
Son: School is so boring. They are teaching calculus, which I already knew since I was 6, and they are still learning Newtonian physics. When are they going to start on quantum mechanics?
Me: Yes, you are a gifted child. But do stay in school, dear. If you find the academic side of the school is boring, try joining student organisations, like the Chinese Language Society or debate team.
Son: Like what you did when you attended high school?
Me: Yes. You can learn about people relationship, people management, organisational skills but most of all it is fun! You could also do some charity work in the local community. By helping the poor and the weak, you get to see things from other people's point of view and it will change your life. You could also play some games, mix with people, go after girls, you know, those things that other high school boys do?! (laugh)
Son: But what's the point?
Me: What's the point of going after girls? (*Gasp*)
Son: No, dad. (=.= "') I know about going after girls. I meant, what's the point of learning people skills, etc ...
Me: Great to hear you are interested in girls already (*wink*). Well, there's a lot more to school than just knowledge, you know. And that's certainly true as well when you step into the society to work, which will happen soon enough. To make the right decision, you must learn how to appreciate the people around you, the culture and history. To realise a plan, you must make people to work with you. You don't expect to get everything done by yourself, do you?
Son: Didnt' Einstein developed theory of relativity all by himself?
Me: No. First of all, without Newton and all the subsequent scientist's groundbreaking work in gravity, there would be no theory of relativity. They were the necessary foundation to Einstein's work. Let's not forget that he had to rely on Eddington to verify his theory. And most important of all, Einstein was not just a physicist, he was also actively involved in politics and was influential in both the World War 1 and 2.
Son: Really? I see.
Me: Your knowledge must have a positive impact to yourself, to the people around you and ultimately to humanity, but you would not be able to do that if you do not first appreciate and respect the people around you. What good is knowledge if it doesn't help yourself and those around you?
Son: Does it always come in that order? Self, people around me, and then humanity? Sounds a bit far-fetched don't you think? Humanity, eh?
Me: Your sphere of influence grows in that order - you first influence yourself, the people around you and then, if you are lucky, humanity. But the importance is in the reverse order. Always place others before yourself. You will never know though, that some day you may be some one great and influential. But even if you are not the leader of the world, you are always important to me, to your family and those around you.
Son: Thanks dad.
Me: You are welcome. Remember, stay in school. Spend the extra time with friends and learn more about people, it's much more complex than quantum mechanics and string theory, trust me on it. There's no hurry in learning quantum physics and string theory. You can always accelerate your academic skills after high school when you start your university education. So what do you think? You feel better about school now?
Son: I guess so. I will check out the notice board tomorrow to see if any student project interests me.
Me: Good. Now, go out and play with your friends.
Son: OK. But I think I would go to my room and finish the book "The strange theory of light and matter" by Feynman. I am already at the last chapter. Love you, dad.
Me: Love you too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
